|
|
|
As new technologies quickly come into play, it becomes increasingly
difficult for published research to keep pace in evaluating their
usefulness for literacy and learning (Kamil & Lane, 1998).
Leu, Karchmer & Leu (1999) argue that the evaluation of effective
literacy strategies will increasingly fall to classroom teachers
who use these new technologies on a daily basis. They describe
a phenomenon called the "Miss Rumphius Effect" in which
our more experienced colleagues share new visions of literacy
learning, resources, strategies, and expertise to inform teaching.
Miss Rumphius, the main character in Barbara Cooney's beloved
picture book of the same name, sows seeds of the lupine
flower to make the world a more beautiful place. Like Miss Rumphius,
these technological pathfinders will sow the seeds of knowledge
to support us in our use of technology to enhance and to transform
literacy learning.
This article highlights the work of three New England teachers
in their use of technology. Our travels begin at the Ella F. Hoxie
School in Bourne, Cape Cod in Ms. Susan Pandiani's third grade
classroom. Next we are off to Mr. Steven Woznicki's fourth grade
classroom at the Florence E. Smith Elementary School of Science,
Math and Technology in West Hartford, Connecticut. Finally, our
travels will take us back across New England, to Ms. Marjorie
Duby's fifth grade class at the Joseph Lee School in Boston, Massachusetts.
Like Miss Rumphius, these teachers work beyond the confines of
"their own gardens" to pioneer and share new ways of
using technology to teach and learn.
The North Star Navigators
The Voyage is Just Beginning...
Set sail with us as we begin a year long exploration of our true
potential.
We believe that we are all gifted, special, creative and multi-smart.
Follow us on this amazing journey of self-discovery as we explore
our talents, gifts, and strengths.
This message is posted on Ms. Pandiani's web page (http://www.capecod.net/voyage/navigators.html)
and serves as the inspirational theme of her classroom. It is
based on a picture book called The North Star written and
illustrated by Peter Reynolds (fondly referred to as "Captain
Peter" by the students) and on her ongoing collaboration
with him. The North Star, which can be accessed on-line
(http://www.fablevision.com/northstar/read.html),
encourages readers to chart their own course in life, while paying
attention to their own guiding signs and North Star along the
way. (In the on-line text of The North Star the reader
has the choice of selecting a version with a male or female starring
as the main character.)
As I entered Ms. Pandiani classroom, she issued the call "Navigators
navigate!" At that point the children looked up, clapped
and gave their attention to their teacher. Ms. Pandiani welcomed
me and explained to the children that they had a visitor who would
spend the day with them in order to learn about the important
work that they do at school. I felt drawn in and charmed by this
intriguing atmosphere.
Throughout the classroom environment the navigational metaphor
was evident. The children worked in teams, which had navigation
related names such as The Queens Fleet, Orion, Scorpio, Leo etc.
Similarly, within their collaborative group, each child had responsibilities
that were described in nautical terms. For example, the quartermaster
was a member of the team whose job was to pass out the paper and
materials to her group.
As I looked around the room I saw ships, paper lanterns and stars
made by the children hanging from the ceiling. The third graders
explained to me that the ships took them on their voyage. The
stars were there to help guide them, while the lanterns helped
to light their way. There was a mural entitled " The North
Star Hemisphere" with the "Isle of Perseverance",
the "Isle of Disrespect", and the like, designed to
help students reflect on the course they are charting and to offer
alternatives for "safe passage". And there was the enchanting
artwork by artist /illustrator Peter Reynolds to inspire dreaming,
imagination, writing, and artwork.
Author/Writer In Residence Via the Internet
Ms. Pandiani's collaboration with Peter Reynolds began in
1996 when she discovered math software (The Graph Club), which
included a little book entitled Fizz & Martina in The
Incredible Not-for Profit Pet Resort Mystery, written and
illustrated by Reynolds. She e-mailed him about how much her students
enjoyed the book, and from this initial contact, a classroom mentoring
relationship developed. Ms. Pandiani shared how early on "Captain
Peter" sent her class a hand written, hand drawn prototype
of his book, The North Star. Later, he sent Ms. Pandiani's
third graders blank paged hardbound books for their own writing.
Thus, was the beginning of her beautiful ongoing friendship and
mentorship with an author/writer.
Ms Pandiani (sometimes playfully and lovingly referred to as "Queen
Pandiani" by her students) explains that Peter Reynolds has
helped her to refine her teaching, especially as it relates to
writing. For example, when third grader Kaela was writing a descriptive
paragraph entitled The Worst Storm Ever, Ms. Pandiani questioned
her use of the word "ponderous" to describe "heavy
rain". In sharing Kaela's paragraph with Reynolds, however,
he thought the choice of the word "ponderous" was brilliant.
Thus, inspired by Kaela's descriptive paragraph, he composed a
poem, Freedom Is Rain, which included the following stanza:
I felt the ponderous rain
pounding on my roof
it made me ponder a pound of ponderings
sitting there listening
to the Ponderous Rain.
When Ms. Pandiani shared Peter's poem with Kaela, Kaela was
inspired to compose her own poem entitled, Ponderous Rain which
is posted on Kaela's web page (http://www.capecod.net/voyage/kaela.html).
Her poem reads:
The ponderous rain soaked the window pain,
making shapes of unimaginable things.
The other things were normal things,
like doorknobs and silver strings.
The ponderous rain makes a gurgling sound
as it whirlpools down the drain.
The pitter patter of the rain
sends sleepy thoughts to my brain.
All this happens as the ponderous rain
soak the window pane.
This incident was not only an important learning experience
for Kaela, but for Ms. Pandiani, as well. So much so, that it
spurred her to write an article about this event which was subsequently
published in The Reading Teacher (1998). 52, (2) 174.
On the day of my visit to Ms. Pandiani's classroom, Hoxie school
was preparing for the celebration of its 90th anniversary. The
children were making posters to publicize this event in storefront
windows in town. They also decided to send an e-mail to Captain
Peter to invite him to this event. The children sat on the rug
in the meeting area viewing the monitor while Queen Pandiani keyboarded
their collaborative composition. Together, they went through the
drafting, revising, and editing process until they were satisfied
with their communication. It read:
Dear Captain Peter,
Here is a picture of us. How are you doing on your journey?
The Navigators hope that you are sailing smoothly. We are doing
great! We worked well with the substitute when the Queen was in
Sacramento. That made her happyJ
Peter, would you like to join us for Hoxie's 90th Birthday Celebration?
If you can't come to Hoxie School on Friday, would you like to
write an acrostic poem for the Navigator's Web site? We would
love it!!!!!!!! Please write back to us and let us know when you
can visit us.
FYNS (Follow Your North Star)
And UYI (Use Your Imagination)
Love,
Your Navigators and Queen Pandiani
In addition to designing posters and writing to Captain Peter,
the children rotated onto the six computer stations (one designated
for each of the six collaborative groups) in order to make a star
page (an individual Web page for their Discover a Star
page) and to key in a biographical statement (each page also includes
a name acrostic poem) for their web page. Students were also using
the on-line MapMaker software to create their own constellation
of guiding stars. Ms. Pandiani orchestrated the process, scaffolding
the work of individuals at the computer stations, as well as supporting
the work of the larger group.
In Ms. Pandiani classroom technology is used primarily as a communicational
tool. Students write letters back to Captain Peter. They post
their work on their classroom web page, and read the writings
of parents and grandparents posted on their web page, as well.
Ms. Pandiani explains that "it takes a fleet to raise a child",
speaks of her North Star Classroom as being part of that fleet.
Technology provides an important tool for maintaining connections
among its sojourners. Her third graders, the North Star Navigators,
began their journey as first and second graders when they were
North Star Junior Navigators. They will become the North Star
Guides in grade four, and will develop into full-fledged Voyagers
in middle school. Ms. Pandiani proudly shares the archives of
writing posted on her web page done by her students, their sisters,
brothers, parents and grandparents. Additionally, she signals
her community to keep in touch on-line by "putting their
messages into a bottle" and by casting them into the "cyber
ocean" (http://www.capecod.net/voyage/fleet.html).
Good morning possessors of magnificent minds!
As I already mentioned to you, we are enjoying a visitor today.
Please make sure you say "hello" to Ms. Kurkjian and
make her feel welcome.
We have a full day of learning and fun today so please be ready
to begin at 8:40 by having your Wake-up Work journal on your desk.
By the way, careful editors, can you find two punctuation,
grammar, or spelling mistakes I made in this message?
Yours fondly,
Mr. Woznicki
This was the morning message that was posted on Mr. Woznicki's
overhead monitor as his students entered their fourth grade classroom
at the Florence E. Smith School, Magnet School of Science, Math
and Technology in West Hartford, Connecticut. As the school day
began, the children gathered their materials, read the posted
message and began to settle into their day. Just by using this
message, Mr. Woznicki greeted his students, welcomed this visitor
to the class, focused them on their morning work, and helped them
to practice their editing skills. As. Mr. Woznicki walked his
students though editing the message, scaffolding when necessary,
individual students keyed in corrections.
On the day of my visit I had the opportunity to observe several
ways Mr. Woznicki uses technology to support, enhance, and transform
literacy learning and teaching. The range of strategies I observed
often shared a combination of the following characteristics: 1)
using technology functionally to solve everyday problems,
2) enhancing familiar teaching strategies, 3) expanding curriculum,
and
4) distributing expertise and responsibilities among members of
the community.
Magnificent Minds and the Functional Use of Technology
Mr. Woznicki believes that it is not necessary to artificially
seek out ways to use technology per se, because it naturally presents
its benefits as a teaching and learning tool. Therefore, he does
not consider technology as an "add- on", but as integral
to everyday activities. Mr. Woznicki explains that he uses technology
in the planning of his curriculum, the gathering resources and
materials, and in the presenting/teaching of the curriculum. Similarly,
children use technology as a tool to solve their own specific
problems. I observed an example of this at recess when a fourth
grade student used the computer to articulate the rules of Four
Square, a game the children regularly play at that time. She explained
to me that there was an ongoing dispute about the rules and so
she was keying them into the computer so that they could be referenced
and discussed. I saw another example of embedding technology into
ongoing activities when a fourth grader whose job it was to take
attendance and lunch count for that week nonchalantly relayed
this information to the office via e-mail.
Magnificent Minds and the Enhancement of Familiar Strategies
On the day of my visit Mr. Woznicki integrated technology
with some "old favorite" instructional strategies. "The
Morning Message" is a familiar technique that was enhanced
when, using a word processor, Mr. Woznicki easily and effectively
posted his message on the overhead monitor. A digitized photograph
of himself was also incorporated into the message, adding a dramatic
and personalized touch. The display of the Morning Message on
the monitor helped to create a shared focus among community members.
Moreover, fourth graders were empowered to take responsibility
in the editing process by keying in their corrections that were
displayed on the overhead monitor.
The K-W-L framework (Ogle, 1986) for expository text is a strategy
familiar to most teachers. The K phase (What We Know) helps students
to activate their background knowledge, the W phase (What we Want
to Know) helps readers to set purposes for their reading, and
finally the L phase (What I Leaned) helps them to consolidate
and articulate what was learned. Here again, Mr. Woznicki used
technology to support and enhance his use of the K-W-L framework.
The students with whom Mr. Woznicki worked during Reading were
collaborating on the L phase and were revisiting their K-W-L chart
(see Figure 1) for Jean Fritz's book, Where Do You Think You're
Going, Christopher Columbus? The learners had a copy of the
previously completed chart, and referred to it as they discussed
and searched in their books to locate unanswered questions. At
the same time, Mr. Woznicki posted the K-W-L chart on the monitor
and as children discussed their responses to the questions, he
keyed the information for all to view and discuss.
Magnificent Minds and the Augmentation of Curriculum
The Florence E. Smith School is a Science, Math and Technology
Magnet School. Science is an important focus and technology augments
the study of science. On the day of my visit NASA was launching
its Polar Expedition to Mars. On the front board Mr. Woznicki
posted the address of the NASA web site which was documenting
this expedition. In keeping with a theme of study on exploration,
he capitalized on a "teachable moment" by engaging his
students in a lively discussion about the landing. He piqued their
curiosity about this event by inviting questions, and by encouraging
them to visit the bookmarked web site at recess or at home.
Technology also supports the curriculum in a science-related activity
referred to as the "Micro Mystery of the Week". For
this activity a fourth grader, Kevin, was responsible for challenging
the class to identify a sample of something that was magnified
and projected onto the monitor through the use of a FlexCam. The
whole class was able to view the magnified material, to make observations
and to ask questions in order to identify the substance. Using
an observation sheet the children described its color, shape,
texture and composition. Light was held up to the magnified sample
allowing the children to consider whether the substance was transparent,
translucent or opaque. Finally, Kevin took questions from the
class. Findings included that the substance was edible. It was
not soft like a sponge. It was not sweet like candy. It was not
breakable like pasta noodles. Several guesses were made, however,
although some guesses came close, no one guessed that the substance
they were examining was breadcrumbs. Because Kevin succeeded in
stumping his classmates, he won the right to challenge them next
week with a new sample.
One of the major components in the fourth grade science curriculum
at the Florence E. Smith School is the study of weather. This
is done in part through a thematic unit in which students engage
in a variety of hands-on activities. Students make use of HyperStudio,
a multimedia-authoring tool, to support them in their research
of weather phenomenon (Kurkjian, 1998). So in collaboration with
the media specialist, Mrs. Lucy Leone, the students in Mr. Woznicki's
class learn how to use resources such as books, encyclopedias
and the Internet appropriately. Additionally, in the context of
developing research strategies, they have the opportunity to create
a report in an engaging multimedia format.
Technology strengthens the study of weather in the opportunity
it provides the students to participate in an actual ongoing NASA
Research Project. Fourth graders collect weather data on a weekly
basis and then upload it to the NASA site. At recess time a rotating
group of students gather this data, measuring minimum and maximum
temperatures, rainfall, and describing cloud covers. One saw the
pride and satisfaction of young researchers as they carefully
took these measurements and uploaded them to the NASA site.
Magnificent Minds and the Distribution of Expertise
Mr. Woznicki holds the expectation that his students will
share the responsibility for the teaching and learning, and utilize
technology in that process. Students are encouraged to be technology
users and to take the lead in teaching and in supporting each
other in their learning. For example, as part of the "Wake
up Work" posted in the Morning Message, the fourth graders
were asked to analyze data that they themselves provided in their
responses to "The Question of the Week" which was "What
is the last digit of your telephone number?". Brett, a member
of the class, compiled the data, then created and presented a
bar graph on the overhead monitor for his classmates to read and
interpret. Similarly, students are encouraged to review, evaluate
and present highlights of new educational software to their classmates.
Mr. Woznicki distributes expertise among the members of his class
during "pre"computer lab workshop sessions, as well.
Prior to taking his students to the media center to work on their
HyperStudio Weather Projects, he invites them to share some of
the problems they are having on their projects, and encourages
those who have already solved the same problem to explain their
solutions. At times, Mr. Woznicki uses the overhead monitor displaying
the HyperStudio Program to demonstrate the process in collaboration
with expert classmates. During this "pre" computer lab
workshop time, Mr. Woznicki also requests that classmates share
their exciting discoveries. Finally, Mr. Woznicki encourages collaboration
and the sharing of expertise during the actual computer lab time
when he reminds his students to strategically seat themselves
next to classmates who have already solved the problems on which
they are currently working.
Mr. Woznicki speaks of his students as being members of a classroom
community in which they are responsible for doing their part and
for doing as much as possible for themselves. This stance applies
to their use of technology, in that he empowers students to use
it in their everyday ongoing activities as a natural part of what
they do. He believes that children are in-part responsible to
learn and discover from their own mistakes and so he arranges
the environment so that they are in a positive and scaffolded
environment in which risk taking is permitted. He believes that
when expectations are high, students rise to the occasion. Moreover,
when it comes to technology, he acknowledges that a great deal
of expertise resides within the classroom community.
Massachusetts Bay Colonists and their Looney Lobsters
The Cyber-British are coming! We are in Ms. Marjorie Duby's
classroom at the Joseph Lee School in Boston, Massachusetts where
history is coming to life for her fifth graders. Ms. Duby's class
is in the midst of studying the American Revolution. Students
are reading the book My Brother Sam is Dead (Lincoln Collier
& Collier, 1974) taking field trips to historic sites, and
participating in simulations of personas from the Revolutionary
War time period. And Ms. Duby is using technology as a tool throughout
this unit of study to enhance and support their learning.
Because Ms Duby's class is located in the heart of Boston, she
and her students take advantage of the opportunity to participate
in educational programs at actual historic sites in the area.
For example, they recently visited the Adams National Historic
Site in Quincy, Massachusetts where they reenacted the Boston
Massacre. Dressed in British and colonial costumes, her students
simulated the events of this incident right down to the hurling
of (in this case Styrofoam) snowballs.
On the day of my visit the fifth graders were preparing for an
upcoming field trip to the Old South Church where they would engage
in a debate by taking on personas of actual historical figures
who were in attendance at the Boston Tea Party Meeting of 1773.
Ms. Duby provided her class with short sketches of the actual
historical characters in preparation for their reenactment of
this meeting.
Ms. Duby encourages her students to explore various perspectives,
including the points of view of "the invisibles" of
the time, those people such as women, Africans, servants, apprentices,
Native Americans, whose voices are not normally heard in the typical
course of studying the American Revolution. She uses simulations
of real and fictitious characters of the period as one way to
engage her students in this perspective taking.
How Does Technology Fit?
During the course of study, and as part of these simulations,
Ms. Duby's fifth graders participate in an Internet Project with
another group of fifth graders in Maple Valley, Washington. For
this project each student in Ms. Duby's class portrays a fictitious
character from the Massachusetts Bay Colony, and, likewise, each
student in the partner class depicts characters from Newportia
Colony, a fictitiously based on a middle colony in Pennsylvania.
Each classroom community describes their colonial charter, participates
in colonial town meetings and issues and responds to challenges
posed by their partner class. An outline of this Internet Project,
complete with character profiles examples of challenges and responses,
is posted at (http://lee.boston.k12.ma.us/d4/curr/rev/colsim/colonial.asp).
An example of a challenge that the Massachusetts Bay Colony issued
to Newportia Colony revolved around the theme of witchcraft. Ms.
Duby's class posed a situation in which characters in the Newportia
Colony were accused of being witches. Warrants for arrest were
issued to specific members in the Newportia Colony:
Warrant 1: The Magistrates of Newportia Colony order that Elizabeth Smith be brought to Newportia Jail until she is examined, brought to face her accuser and finally brought to trial for witchcraft. Marion Blue accuses Elizabeth Smith of looking at his cow wrongly. The next day the cows would not eat. Elizabeth Smith is accused of witchcraft!
The class in Washington responded to this challenge by sharing
what happened to the characters as a result of the warrants. In
an exchange posted on the web we learned, for example, that Elizabeth
Smith escaped from jail on the day of the trial, and that there
were reports that she took ill and was being nursed back to health
by Quakers in a nearby colony.
In addition to participating in this Internet Project, each fifth
grader uses technology to enhance their study of the American
Revolution by creating a PowerPoint slide on their assigned character.
Each slide includes a digitized image of the student dressed as
the character being simulated, along with a written description
of the character. On the day of my visit students worked in the
computer lab revising their slide using a rubric that Ms. Duby
provided.
Between bites at lunchtime, Ms. Duby explained that she uses technology
as a tool to achieve a variety of curriculum objectives. Technology
plays an important, but not necessarily a central role in her
program. Because an area of focus for this year is on writing,
she created an American Revolutionary Period writing web page:
Here one can find writing challenges pertaining to the Revolutionary
theme. Additionally, she uses technology to encourage writing
by providing her students with e-mail accounts. Once again through
simulations, students are challenged to correspond with each other
and to characters living in England (these messages are received
and answered by Ms. Duby, herself!) in the persona they are depicting.
Ms. Duby uses her web site as a way of gathering resources for
her students to use. Just as teachers gather library books and
other material, she posts interesting resources on her web page
for student review. And like Miss Rumphius, the intent of her
web page is to share it with other educators. Her overall site
for the Revolutionary period is at (http://lee.boston.k12.ma.us/x1/revper.asp).
When you visit this site you can gain access to an extensive lists
of primary, secondary and Intenet resources which even include
links to field trip sites.
Who are the Looney Lobsters?
At the end of the day, Ms. Duby called a class meeting. She
removed two fire engine red lobsters (stuffed, not real!) from
a box and announced that these crustaceans would be visiting a
class in D.C. Ms. Duby invited her class to write an entry into
the log that would be accompanying them.
"The Looney Lobsters" are the characters in an Internet
Project that Ms. Duby developed in which these two classroom mascots
travel to various schools across the United States and then eventually
return back home. The original purpose of this project was to
gather various types of information about the places they were
visiting. Some of the educational activities that Ms. Duby's class
engaged in for this Internet Project include: 1) computing of
how far and where the Looneys have traveled, locating the longitude
and latitude of each destination, 2) noting time zones of various
destinations, 3) observing the weather of the host school as compared
to Boston weather, 4) obtaining suggested literature for read
alouds to lower grade Book Buddies, and 5) reading regional literature.
Ms. Duby posts the collected information on her web page (http:lee.boston.k12.ma.us/d4/trav/lroot.asp
). As I left Ms. Duby's classroom a student who escorted me
to the door volunteered that Miss Duby is a teacher who always
has a smile on her face and something good to say. Following in
the tradition of "Miss Rumphius" Ms. Duby works to make
the world a more beautiful place, not only for her students but
for colleagues as well.
Envisionments for Literacy and Learning
Leu, Karchmer & Leu (1999) refer to a process termed "envisionment"
in which teachers and their students dream of new possibilities
for literacy learning and teaching, use technology in ways which
help to create this new vision, and then share their work with
others. This issue spotlighted three technological pathfinders
each with their own unique envisionment. In the sharing of their
work, resources, strategies, Ms. Pandiani, Mr. Woznicki, and Ms.
Duby clearly demonstrate the "Miss Rumphius Effect"
by planting seeds which serve to enrich our instructional worldview.
References
Kamil, M.L., & Lane, D.M. (1998). Researching the relationship
between technology and literacy: An agenda for the 21 st Century.
In D. Reinking, M. McKenna, L.D. Labbo, & R. Kieffer (Eds.),
Handbook of literacy and technology: Transformations in a post-typographic
world (pp. 323-342). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
Kurkjian, C., and (1998) Software in Context: HyperStudio Projects.
NERA Journal, 34(1), 23-28.
Leu, D.J., Karchmer, R.A. & Diadiun Leu (1999). The Miss Rumphius
Effect: Envisionments for literacy learning that transform the
Internet. Reading Online, http://readingonline.org/electronic/RT/rumphius.html
Ogle, D. (1986). K-W-L: A teaching model that develops active reading of expository text. The Reading Teacher, 39, 564-570.
Children's Literature References
Cooney, B. (1982). Miss Rumphius: Viking
Collier, J. & Collier, C. (1974). My Brother Sam Is Dead: Delacorte
Fritz, J. (1980). Where Do You Think You're Going Christopher, Columbus?: Putnam
Reynolds, P. (1997). The North Star: FableVision Press
Reynolds, P. (1993) Fizz & Martina in the Incredible Not-for
Profit Pet Resort: Tom Snyder Productions, Inc..
|
|
|
|